Free cultures are cultures that leave a great deal open for others to build upon; unfree, or permission, cultures leave much less. Ours was a free culture. It is becoming much less so.Is it right to copy? Why?
Is it bad to set rules so that people can't copy? Why?
Imagine when your precious work that you've done earlier got copied by the others, how would you feel? If you answer nothing, that's plain lie! A total lie.
Honestly won't you mind people copying your work?
Example:
Naruto, one of the most famous manga in Japan.
And this is the doujinshi
How would the person who created this feel after they saw this? They go through sleepless night just to come out with the concept, the characteristic, the storyline and the others just copy without crediting them? It's even worse if the doujinshi got almost the same viewing rates as the original one. Where their hard work gone?
Not only comics but also,
Last Friends (Japanese Drama)
(Taiwan Drama)
Just so you know, these two drama, have two different story line. They just copy the concept of the poster.
Copyright is to protect the original works. Look, what if this world has no copyright?
No one will ever want to come out with new creations anymore! But one thing is that lecturers will be very happy as they got their job easier. Why? Imagine, when there is no copyright, the word "plagiarism" gone as well. Which means, students can copy whatever things they want to and ended up having the same content!
Hence, in the original creator's mind, copyright is to protect them. Just like protecting people from stealing something from their brain.
But on the other hand, it also restrict us in some way. For example, a song writer, even though they've heard over 100,000 of songs, it's impossible for them to listen to everything. And when they start creating works, even though they might not have intention to copy, they might ended up just sound almost the same as one of the songs in the other end of the world. What's next? The news will spread to everyone everywhere and from a song writer, he/she will then "evolve" into a copycat. Sad isn't it? Why what can they do?
There was once, my friend told me this,
Friend: Hey! My lecturer said I plagiarized. And guess who is the one I copied from?
Me : Uhm, some very famous scholar's journal?
Friend: Wrong guess! Try again.
Me : The textbook?
Friend: No! It's a 12 year old kid from America!
Me : Wh-Wh-What?? How do they find out in the first place?
Friend: Apparently, they have this software where when they put the soft copy of your work in,
it'll scanned through and check how much you've plagiarized. If it's over 40%, that means you plagiarized and the lecturer will confront you. And this is how I got it.
Me : Wow, that's...scary. So what you plagiarized.
Friend: The word "In a nutshell"
Me : WHAT?!
I don't know how true is it but this is what I heard from him. If every single thing is copyrighted, we'll then have very limited spaces to express our ideas.
Even though it's bad to copy, but sometimes, when ideas build on ideas, it does turned way better and more effective. Ask yourself, why Cinderella from Brother's Grimm isn't as famous as Cinderella recreated by Disney? When you were young, don't you think that Cinderella is original story from Disney? Honestly, I do thought so.
So, is copyright something right or wrong? No one can answer that. It's in between right and wrong. You'll get different answer depending on how you interpret it.
However, there are still a way to make this problem smaller. Which I think is a win win situation. Taking the doujinshi as an example, when you copy other's work, pay for it. With this way, the original creator got compensated and you get to use the characters and build on more ideas. Isn't it good?
Example,
This is the original work of Hana Kimi,
Then Taiwan re-act this in drama,
Next come to Japan,
and another version from the Japanese.
As for what I know, these are all paid. When the original creator got paid for this, the audiences can enjoy the different way of portraying the characters as well. Don't you think this is a win-win situation?
In a nutshell, there is still no fix line what should be copyrighted and what should not be. It depends on how people want to think about it. Sometimes, even though you might not have the intention to copy, you might end up being told copying. The world is too big for us to know everything. Hence, free culture is good in a way but also, because of copyright, plenty of creative ideas vanished just like that.















